By Imogen Bliss, Rosie Gearey, Lea May Anderson, and Caitlin Hafferty

This Plain Language Summary is published in advance of the paper discussed. Please check back soon for a link to the full paper.

Image: opensource image from Pixabay

How are local communities carving their own space within a nature restoration landscape that requires measurements, verification and market-translatability? This is a question we ask in this Perspective piece. Nature restoration in Scotland, and across the UK, is central to addressing climate change and biodiversity loss, and nature markets in particular are a key focus of current government policies. However, the language of markets – terms such as private investment, blended finance, carbon credits and so on – do not always align with the ways in which communities relate to nature, nor do they always capture the concerns and interests of communities. Rather than thinking about this contradiction in binary, either-or, terms, we discuss how communities are already navigating this landscape and finding cracks within dominant systems to reshape, challenge and resist market-focused restoration. Small examples like this offer glimpses of how nature restoration could be stretched beyond easily countable numbers (like tonnes of carbon sequestered, or price of carbon units) to include more social aspects. However, currently these examples remain in the minority, and further support is needed for communities to be able to see real, long-term transformation for themselves within the nature recovery space.